Nursing Essay Ethical Dilemma In Physician-Assisted Death

Physician-assisted death, also known as physician-assisted suicide or assisted dying, is a highly controversial and polarizing topic. It refers to a situation in which a physician provides medication or other means to a terminally ill patient, with the intention of helping them end their own life. This practice is legal in a limited number of countries, such as the Netherlands, Belgium, Luxembourg, Canada, and some states in the United States, but it remains illegal in most of the world. The ethical dilemma surrounding physician-assisted death arises from conflicting values such as the sanctity of life, patient autonomy, and the duty of care that physicians owe to their patients. In this article, we will explore the ethical issues surrounding physician-assisted death, including arguments for and against the practice, and the role of healthcare professionals in navigating this complex issue.

Arguments for Physician-Assisted Death

The main argument in favor of physician-assisted death is patient autonomy. Supporters of the practice argue that terminally ill patients should have the right to decide when and how they die, and that denying them this right is a violation of their personal autonomy and human rights. They argue that patients who are suffering from terminal illnesses, and whose quality of life has significantly deteriorated, should have the option of ending their lives in a dignified manner, rather than being forced to endure unbearable suffering and pain.

Another argument for physician-assisted death is the principle of beneficence. This principle requires physicians to act in the best interests of their patients and to do no harm. Supporters of physician-assisted death argue that by providing terminally ill patients with the means to end their own lives, physicians are acting in their best interests by relieving their suffering and allowing them to die with dignity.

Arguments Against Physician-Assisted Death

Opponents of physician-assisted death argue that it is inherently wrong to intentionally take a human life, regardless of the circumstances. They argue that the sanctity of life is a fundamental principle that should not be compromised, and that allowing physician-assisted death undermines this principle. They also argue that the legalization of physician-assisted death would create a slippery slope, leading to the erosion of ethical standards and the potential for abuse of vulnerable individuals.

Another argument against physician-assisted death is the principle of non-maleficence. This principle requires physicians to avoid causing harm to their patients. Opponents of physician-assisted death argue that intentionally ending a patient’s life is a form of harm, and that physicians have a duty to protect their patients from harm, even if it means prolonging their suffering.

Ethical Issues for Healthcare Professionals

Physicians and other healthcare professionals face a significant ethical dilemma when it comes to physician-assisted death. On the one hand, they have a duty to provide their patients with the best possible care, including relieving their pain and suffering. On the other hand, they also have a duty to protect the sanctity of life and to avoid causing harm to their patients.

One approach to resolving this dilemma is through the principle of double effect. This principle allows for actions that may have both good and bad consequences, as long as the primary intention is to bring about the good consequence, and the bad consequence is an unavoidable side effect. For example, if a physician administers pain medication to a terminally ill patient to relieve their suffering, and the side effect is that the medication may hasten the patient’s death, this would be permissible under the principle of double effect.

However, the principle of double effect may not be applicable in all cases of physician-assisted death. In cases where the primary intention is to end the patient’s life, rather than to relieve their suffering, the principle of double effect may not provide a sufficient ethical justification.

Another approach to resolving the ethical dilemma surrounding physician-assisted death is through a patient-centered approach. This approach focuses on the patient’s values and wishes, and involves open and honest communication between the patient and healthcare professional. The healthcare professional should provide the patient with all available options, including palliative care and hospice care, and should respect the patient’s decision, even if it goes against their own personal beliefs.

The patient-centered approach requires healthcare professionals to balance their duty to protect the sanctity of life with their duty to respect patient autonomy. It also requires them to be sensitive to the emotional and psychological needs of the patient and their family members, and to provide adequate support and counseling throughout the decision-making process.

Conclusion

The ethical dilemma surrounding physician-assisted death is complex and multifaceted. It involves conflicting values such as the sanctity of life, patient autonomy, and the duty of care owed by healthcare professionals to their patients. The arguments for and against physician-assisted death highlight the need for a balanced and nuanced approach to this issue. Healthcare professionals must navigate this complex ethical terrain with sensitivity and compassion, while respecting the wishes and values of their patients. Ultimately, the decision to allow physician-assisted death should be based on a careful consideration of the ethical, social, and legal implications, with the aim of promoting the wellbeing and dignity of terminally ill patients.

Find online help in writing essays, research papers, term papers, reports, movie reviews, annotated bibliographies, speeches/presentations, projects, presentations, dissertation services, theses, research proposals, essay editing, proofreading, Book reviews, article reviews, formatting, personal statements, admission essays, scholarship essays, application papers, among others.

Get top notch writing help from our best tutors !
Paper Writing Help
Excel in your academics in one easy click!

🛒Place Your Order

Scroll to Top